Magnesium Glycinate vs. L-Threonate: Which Is The Best Magnesium Supplement?

Magnesium Glycinate vs. L-Threonate: Which Is The Best Magnesium Supplement?

Posted by Nootropics Depot on 2nd Oct 2018

Two Forms Of Magnesium Supplements With Two Different Uses

Recent research has indicated that many individuals are currently deficient in magnesium. In fact, the numbers are a little bit shocking! Recent scientific reviews claims that up to 50% of Americans have inadequate magnesium intake. This is a problem, as magnesium is used in many processes throughout the body and brain. Due to this, foods that are high in magnesium have become increasingly popular in recent years. However, there are various issues when it comes to relying solely on diet for magnesium. The first issue is consistency. Research has shown that levels of magnesium in foods that should contain high levels are not consistently high in magnesium. In fact, it appears that magnesium levels are dropping across the board in most foods. For example, it has been found that the magnesium content in wheat has dropped a whopping 20% since 1968! The reason for such a dramatic drop appears to be due to three main factors:

1. Acidification of soil.

2. Crop yields increasing, but at the cost of less magnesium in those crops (yield dilution).

3. Unbalanced fertilization of soils.

What Causes Magnesium Deficiency? 

To make matters even worse, many foods that are high in magnesium are also high in phytic acid. Phytic acid has been shown to bind to magnesium, which prevents the bound magnesium from being absorbed. Paired with the declining magnesium content in crops, and the increased consumption of processed foods, this is likely part of the reason why so many people are experiencing magnesium deficiencies. In addition to this, there are also various other factors that have come to light recently that contribute to the prevalence of magnesium deficiency:

1. High consumption of calcium and vitamin D through diet or through supplementation. Calcium competes with magnesium for absorption. Therefore, if more calcium is being consumed than magnesium, then magnesium absorption will become inhibited. Vitamin D leads to increased calcium absorption, and through this mechanism, inhibits magnesium absorption even further.

2. Consumption of soda and foods such as processed meats that contain phosphoric acid.   

3. Sweating during sports - athletes are at risk of magnesium deficiency as magnesium is excreted through sweat.   

4. Consumption of aluminum through aluminum cookware, baked goods/baking powder, and deodorant.

5. Aluminum decreases the absorption of magnesium by five-fold in addition to leading to a 41% decrease in magnesium retention.   

6. Vitamin B 6 deficiency leads to increased magnesium excretion.   

How To Correct Magnesium Deficiency

The most straightforward solution to magnesium deficiency would be to simply supplement magnesium. However, as straightforward as this may seem, it turns out that magnesium supplementation is a little bit tricky. There are three factors that we need to keep in mind when it comes to magnesium supplementation:

1. How much elemental magnesium does it contain?

2. Does it absorb well in the GI tract?

3. Can it use different transporters for absorption?

The first consideration refers to how much actual magnesium is in magnesium salts. For example, magnesium oxide contains 60.5 % elemental magnesium. This makes it an ideal candidate for magnesium supplementation as small doses will provide large amounts of magnesium. In fact, magnesium oxide is the most commonly supplemented form of magnesium currently. It's also the cheapest to produce. However, the issue with magnesium oxide is that it has very poor bioavailability, meaning that most of the elemental magnesium will not be absorbed properly in the GI tract. 

GI Tract Absorption

This is problematic; as large doses of magnesium oxide, in order to compensate for the low bioavailability, will have a significant laxative effect. This is due to the osmotic effect it has in the GI tract. Magnesium oxide also forms insoluble salts with other dietary compounds in the GI tract; which then causes you to excrete it before absorption. In addition, any magnesium salt is going to need to be solvated before it can absorb, and the elemental magnesium separated from the salt to absorb through the ion channels in the GI tract. This is how all elemental minerals are absorbed. They all flow through the ion channels, and they all compete with each other to do so. 

A way around the poor bioavailability is to chelate magnesium with amino acids. By chelating magnesium, an amino acid is attached to the reactive sites of the magnesium ion. By doing this, absorption is increased significantly. 

This is due to various factors:

1. Magnesium chelates can absorb through amino acid transporters in addition to the magnesium transporter.   

2. Magnesium transporter efficiency is enhanced due to pH modification of magnesium. The pH of magnesium can decrease the efficiency of the magnesium transporter, which limits the absorption of magnesium. By buffering the pH with amino acids, magnesium transporter efficacy can be greatly enhanced.   

3. Compounds such as phytic acid can no longer bind to the reactive sites of magnesium, which enhances absorption.   

4. Magnesium, when it comes into contact with water, attracts water molecules. This increases the size of the magnesium ion, which decreases magnesium absorption. Chelation with amino acids, can help limit the amount of water molecules the magnesium ion attracts, thereby enhancing absorption.

Based on the above factors, we came to the conclusion that amino acid chelated magnesium is the best option currently available for highly bioavailable magnesium supplementation. Based on this, the two forms of magnesium that we carry, Magtein and fully chelated magnesium glycinate, are both magnesium amino acid chelates. Now the question is, why carry two different magnesium amino acid chelates? The short answer to this is that the amino acids that are chelated with magnesium have the ability to exert their own unique effects. Each amino acid also has a unique impact on how the magnesium is absorbed and distributed throughout the body. For example,  Magtein is chelated with L-Threonate, an amino acid that plays an important role in the brain and which helps transport magnesium to the brain. For fully chelated  magnesium glycinate, the magnesium is chelated with glycine. Glycine not only has very good pH buffering activity, but it also has calming effects.

Magtein: What Is Magnesium L Threonate Used For?

Magtein Magnesium L-Threonate Quick Facts

Magtein magnesium l threonate is a patented form of magnesium developed by a team of MIT scientists. The main goals when developing Magtein magnesium L-Threonate was to develop a magnesium amino acid chelate that readily made it to the brain. They ended up settling on an amino acid called L-Threonate, which is a metabolite of vitamin C. L-threonate is a unique amino acid which appears to enhance mitochondrial function, synaptic density, and neuroplasticity on its own. It appears to do this partially by elevating neuronal intracellular magnesium levels, which can then act as a second messenger. Based on this, the chelation of magnesium with L-Threonate makes a lot of sense since, L-Threonate is enhancing neuronal intracellular magnesium levels, whilst the magnesium elevates magnesium levels throughout the body and the brain.

L-Threonate also appears to have a high affinity for the brain, as there is 5 times more L-Threonate in the brain than in the body. This is important, as it indicates that magnesium l threonate could be particularly effective at increasing magnesium levels in the brain. In fact, research has indicated that magnesium l threonate is one of the only forms of magnesium that enters the brain at significant levels. Since magnesium plays a major role in various processes throughout the brain that regulate mood and memory, this makes magnesium l threonate a good form of magnesium for brain health.

Magtein Magnesium L-Threonate Study

Magtein Magnesium L-Threonate Study

One of the ways in which magnesium l threonate enhances cognition, is by increasing the density of NR2B containing NMDA receptors. The NMDA receptors play a crucial role in memory and learning, as activation of the NMDA receptor sets in motion a process called long term potentiation (LTP). LTP is one of the main ways by which we encode memories and thus enhancement of LTP through increased NMDA receptor density should support learning and memory. The increased density of NR2B containing NMDA receptors appears to be due to L-Threonate enhancing neuronal intracellular magnesium levels. However, activation of the NMDA receptor can also lead to overexcitation of the brain, which can be detrimental to cognition. Luckily, magnesium is able to block the NMDA receptor in a manner that only very strong signals will activate them. Thus, the magnesium portion of magnesium l threonate is essential in achieving enhanced, but balanced, NMDA activation. In fact, by decreasing the sensitivity of the NMDA receptors (by blocking it), magnesium that is binding to the NMDA receptor will also help up-regulate NMDA receptors even further. The net effect of this is that once a strong enough signal activates the NMDA receptors, the level of activation should be much greater.

All of these benefits have been verified in a magnesium l-threonate MIT study, and overall it seems that magnesium l threonate benefits brain health the most. Other magnesium l threonate benefits, besides being the best form of magnesium for the brain, include:

1. Highly bioavailable, a good choice for adding magnesium back into your diet quickly.   

2. Very mild taste, easy to add to drinking water.   

Magnesium Glycinate Uses:

Magnesium Glycinate Quick FactsMagnesium glycinate, as the name suggests, is magnesium chelated with the amino acid glycine. Glycine is one of the main inhibitory amino acid neurotransmitters; it even has its own receptors, the glycine receptor! Activation of the glycine receptor will relax muscles, promote relaxation, and can even help enhance sleep. Another unique aspect of the glycine receptor, is that it is also located on the NMDA receptor. Here, it acts as a co-agonist for the NMDA receptor. When glycine receptor on the NMDA receptor are activated, it makes the NMDA receptor more sensitive, which could lead to enhanced cognition, and could help promote a positive mood.

So why chelate magnesium with glycine? One of the main reasons for this is that glycine is a very good pH buffer. This is important, as magnesium absorption through the magnesium transporter is highly dependent on pH levels. Since glycine buffers the pH of magnesium, it greatly enhances absorption through the magnesium transporters.

Once magnesium glycinate has been absorbed, glycine detaches from the magnesium and both glycine and magnesium can go to work. Glycine, being an inhibitory neurotransmitter, can have a calming effect throughout the brain and on our muscles. Due to this, magnesium glycinate is the best magnesium for sleep, and we would recommend this form of magnesium to anyone looking to support a healthy sleep cycle.

Overall, magnesium glycinate benefits sleep the most, this is due to both the relationship between magnesium and sleep, in addition to the relationship between glycine and sleep. Other magnesium glycinate benefits include:

1. Relatively affordable for a high bioavailability magnesium supplement.   

2. Contains a higher percentage of elemental magnesium compared to Magtein.

However, in addition to  magnesium glycinate benefits there is also one major drawback. This drawback is its taste. Whereas Magtein is a great magnesium supplement to add to drinking water, magnesium glycinate has an unpleasant taste to it. That being said, this taste is fairly easy to mask in sour and sweet beverages, such as fruit juices.

Who Should Take a Magnesium Supplement?

As discussed earlier, magnesium deficiency is very common, and thus, most people could benefit from consuming a little bit more magnesium. That being said, individuals who have a lot of muscle cramps could greatly benefit from consuming more magnesium, as cramps can result from a magnesium imbalance. Furthermore, anyone looking to support cognitive function, and promote a positive mood could benefit a lot from consuming a little extra magnesium. On top of this, anyone who drink alcohol would benefit from taking magnesium. Alcohol depletes both magnesium and vitamin B6 in the body. So after a night out drinking, a good magnesium supplement is a must to get your body back in balance.

Magnesium Glycinate Vs. Magnesium L-Threonate: Which Form Of Magnesium Is Best?

Magnesium Glycinate vs. Magnesium L-Threonate

A magnesium glycinate supplement is a lot cheaper than a Magtein magnesium l threonate supplement, and contains more elemental magnesium than Magtein (14 % vs. 8 %). Thus, for anyone simply looking to include a little bit more magnesium in their daily regimen, a magnesium glycinate supplement is the best choice. Magnesium glycinate would also be the best choice for anyone looking for a more relaxing magnesium; especially if they have trouble sleeping. Magnesium l threonate on the other hand is by far the best choice for anyone looking to support cognitive function, due to the magnesium l threonate benefits on overall cognition. Best of all, this has been proven in numerous research studies. The one drawback is that if you are trying to hit the recommended daily intake of 400 mg elemental magnesium, then Magtein is a very expensive option compared to magnesium glycinate. Thus, we would recommend the following: Take Magtein earlier in the day, to reap the cognitive benefits. Then later in the day or at night, take magnesium glycinate. By supplementing both forms, you will be consuming more elemental magnesium, while also promoting relaxation, good sleep and optimal brain health.

Buy Magtein Magnesium L-Threonate Capsules

Buy Magtein Capsules
Magnesium L-Threonate | 667mg

Magnesium Glycinate Capsules
Buy Magnesium Glycinate Capsules
Fully Chelated Magnesium | 800mg

Buy Magtein Magnesium L-Threonate Powder
Buy Magtein Magnesium L-Threonate Powder
Buy Magnesium Glycinate Powder
Buy Magnesium Glycinate Powder

Fully Chelated Magnesium

View more Nootropics Depot blog articles by clicking the links below:

The Best Supplements to Support Collagen Synthesis and Skin Health

Ashwagandha Benefits: An Ayuverdic Herb For Stress Support, Immune Health, and Restful Sleep

CoQSol-CF CoEnzyme Q10: The Superior CoQ10 Supplement Over Grocery Store Brands

The Top 5 Milk Thistle Health Benefits

A Closer Look At The Top 5 Taurine Benefits

Melatonin Supplements: Did You Know This Popular Over The Counter Sleep Aid Is Often Overdosed?

How To Boost Your Immune System With the 5 Best Immune Supplements

Nootropics Depot's Guide to the Top 10 Natural Nootropics of 2018

EpiCor Immune Health: The Natural Immune Boost Supplement You May Not Know About

Nigella Sativa: The Top Health Benefits of Black Seed Oil Extract

Cognizin Citicoline: A Choline Supplement That Supports Healthy Brain Function

7,8-Dihydroxyflavone: A Brain Health Supplement That May Support Neuroplasticity

Creatine: A Nootropic for Bodybuilders, Athletes, Vegans, Vegetarians Alike

How to Find the Best Curcumin Supplement and What to Know Before You Buy

Comparing Rhodiola rosea Extracts: Rosavins vs. Salidroside

Berberine: A Look at the Potential Benefits of this Versatile Supplement

Lion's Mane Mushroom: Comparing our 1:1: and 8:1 Extracts

Nitric Oxide Boosters Reviewed: L-Citrulline, Agmatine and AAKG

Red Reishi Mushrooms: Comparing our 1:1 and 8:1 Extracts

Comprehensive Guide to the Best Anti-Aging Supplements

Cordyceps Militaris Mushrooms: Comparing our 1:1 and 10:1 Extracts

Bacognize vs. Synapsa: Which Ayurvedic Herb is Right for You?

The Nootropic Synergy of Caffeine + L-Theanine

L-Citrulline vs. L-Citrulline DL-Malate: Which is Best?

Shilajit: A Look at this Amazing Ayurvedic Compound

The Ultimate Guide to Nootropics

Mushroom Extracts: Whole Fruiting Bodies vs. Mycelium On Grain

Teacrine: The Alternative to Caffeine

Zembrin: A Natural Way to Boost Your Mood

Ashwagandha: KSM-66 vs. Sensoril

Panax Ginseng: What You Might Not Know

Palmitoylethanolamide: Known for its Pain Reducing Qualities

Put to the Test: A Look at Nootropics Depot's Purity Testing

Browse More From Nootropics Depot

Buy Adaptogen SupplementsBuy Choline SupplementsBuy Nootropics for EnergyBuy Fish Oil SupplementsBuy Mitochondrial Support SupplementsBuy Mushroom Extract SupplementsBuy NootropicsBuy Nootropic CapsulesBuy Nootropic Samples

Ayurveda  |  Adaptogens |  Amino Acids |  Choline Supplements |  Fitness Supplements |  Immune Support |  Metabolism Supplements  |  Mushroom Extracts |  Natural Plant Extracts  |  Natural Nootropic Capsules |  Natural Pain Support |  Patented Nootropic Extracts  |  Sleep Support Supplements  |  Softgels |  Solutions + Sublinguals  |  Enteric Coated Tablets  |  Nootropic Samples

Attention: These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.